How far should presidential power reach?
Roosevelt held that a president may do anything the public good requires unless the Constitution or the laws forbid it — his “stewardship” theory of the presidency. His successor, William Howard Taft, answered that a president may exercise only those powers that can be traced to a specific grant in the Constitution or an act of Congress.
Roosevelt’s view
Roosevelt believed an energetic executive was the people’s steward against concentrated private power, and he used executive orders, public appeals and mediation to act where Congress was slow.
Taft’s view
Taft, who later became chief justice, warned that an undefined reservoir of executive power invited abuse, and many conservatives have since shared his concern about presidential overreach.
